Your Experience Modification May Be Wrong, and It Could Be Costing You

Your experience modification factor, often called an experience mod, X-mod, or EMR, compares your business's actual workers' compensation losses with the losses expected for businesses of similar size in the same classifications. A mod of 1.00 is generally considered average. A mod above 1.00 typically increases your premium, while a mod below 1.00 typically reduces it. Because the calculation relies on several years of payroll, classification, and claims data reported by insurers and other parties, errors can occur, and an incorrect mod can raise premiums for multiple years before anyone notices.

This matters because the mod is applied to your workers' compensation premium every policy year it is in effect, and in industries such as construction, many project owners and general contractors consider a contractor's mod when deciding who can bid. One thing owners consistently underestimate is that the mod is a calculation they can review, question, and in many cases correct, rather than a fixed number assigned to them.

How the Experience Mod Is Calculated

Experience mods are generally calculated by a rating organization, either the National Council on Compensation Insurance or an independent rating bureau in states that use one. The calculation typically uses a multi-year experience period that ends before the most recent policy year. It compares the business's actual reported losses with expected losses based on its payroll in each workers' compensation classification. Rating formulas generally weigh the frequency of claims more heavily than their size, and some rating systems give reduced weight to medical-only claims. The exact formula and rules vary by state and rating organization.

Where Experience Mod Errors Commonly Come From

Incorrect Payroll

Payroll reported for each classification drives expected losses. If payroll was reported incorrectly to the insurer, or audit adjustments were not reflected in the data sent to the rating organization, the expected losses in the calculation may be wrong. Accurate payroll records by classification are the foundation of a correct mod (see payroll processing and reporting).

Wrong Classification Codes

Each employee's work is assigned to a classification code with its own expected loss rate. If employees are placed in the wrong classification, the expected losses can be overstated or understated, distorting the mod. Classification errors are especially common in businesses whose operations have changed over time.

Overstated Claim Reserves

Open claims are typically included in the calculation at their reserve amount, which is the insurer's estimate of the claim's ultimate cost. If reserves are set too high, or a claim closed for less than the reserve but the lower value was not reflected when data was reported, the mod may be higher than it should be. In practice, this usually shows up as an older claim still carried at a large reserve long after the employee has returned to work.

Claims That Don't Belong to You

Occasionally, claims are attributed to the wrong employer, duplicated, or reported under the wrong policy. Reviewing loss runs line by line can surface claims that should not be included.

Recoveries That Were Not Reflected

When an insurer recovers claim costs from a responsible third party, the recovery may reduce the loss used in the calculation, depending on the rules that apply. If recoveries are not reported, the mod may reflect a higher loss than the business actually bore.

Ownership Changes

Mergers, acquisitions, entity changes, and ownership transfers can affect whether prior experience carries over to a new entity. If these changes are reported incorrectly or not at all, a business may inherit experience that should not apply or lose experience that should.

How Much Can an Incorrect Mod Cost?

A question business owners often ask is whether small errors really make a difference. Because the mod is applied directly to premium, even a modest change in the factor can have a noticeable effect, and because each policy year's data typically affects several future mods, an error can carry forward over multiple years. For contractors, a higher mod can also affect eligibility for certain projects, which may cost more than the premium difference itself.

How to Review Your Experience Mod

What we see most often is that the most effective reviews follow a consistent sequence. Request your current experience rating worksheet, which shows the payroll, classifications, and claims used in the calculation. Obtain loss runs from each insurer for the experience period. Compare reported payroll and classifications with your payroll and audit records. Review every claim listed, confirming that it belongs to your business and that open claims carry reasonable reserves. Ask the insurer or claims adjuster about claims that have closed or could be closed, and whether recoveries were reported. If you find errors, work with your insurance broker or carrier to request corrections through the applicable rating organization's process, noting that timing and procedures can matter. A broader insurance review can also catch related issues (see our article on what a coverage gap analysis reveals).

Can You Improve Your Mod Going Forward?

Another common question is what a business can do beyond correcting errors. Because frequency of claims typically carries significant weight, preventing injuries and managing claims well can improve the mod over time. Common practices include safety programs and training, prompt reporting of injuries, active communication with injured employees and adjusters, and return-to-work programs that allow employees to resume modified duties when appropriate. These efforts take time to appear in the mod because of the lag in the experience period, which is why starting early matters (see risk management and safety program support).

Where to Start

Your experience modification may be wrong because it depends on years of payroll, classification, claims, and ownership data reported by multiple parties, and errors in any of them can raise your premium for years. Reviewing your rating worksheet and loss runs, correcting inaccurate data, and managing claims proactively can lower costs and protect your eligibility for work, particularly for construction businesses. If you have not reviewed your mod recently, requesting your worksheet and loss runs is a practical place to start. Secure Accounting can help review your mod alongside your payroll and insurance records through our business insurance services. When you are ready, start a conversation with our team.

This is general information, not advice. The right answer depends on your structure, your state and your specific facts. Talk to us about your situation.

Related insights

Article

The Internal Controls Gap Many Small Businesses Don’t Know They Have

Many small businesses run on trust: a long-time bookkeeper, a reliable office manager, or the owner handling everything personally. Trust is valuable, but it is not a control. The gap most owners do not see is that no one independently checks the people and processes that move money, change payroll, add vendors, or grant system access. This article explains where that gap usually hides, why it persists even in well-run businesses, and the practical checks a small team can put in place without adding headcount.

Article

Long-Term Contractors Are the Classification Risk Many Businesses Ignore

Many contractor relationships start out clearly independent: a defined project, the contractor’s own tools, their own schedule. Then the project ends and the work continues, month after month, until the contractor is working set hours, reporting to a manager, and doing core work alongside employees. That gradual drift is one of the most common ways businesses end up with workers who look like employees. This article explains how contractor drift happens, why long tenure increases risk, and how to review and correct these relationships.

Article

Why Payroll Tax Rules Get More Complicated the Moment You Cross State Lines

Running payroll in one state quickly becomes routine. Add an employee in a second state and the work changes: new tax accounts, different withholding forms, separate unemployment rates and wage bases, state-specific leave and disability programs, possible local taxes, and different rules for pay timing and final paychecks. Each state adds its own calendar of deposits and filings. This article explains what changes when payroll crosses state lines, where errors usually start, and how to keep multi-state payroll accurate.

Applies to you?

Find out where you really stand.

Most of what we write about is quantifiable for your specific business in a short conversation.