Remote workers face a double taxation risk when two states each claim the right to tax the same wages and the employee's home state does not give full credit for the tax paid to the other. In most cases, the system is designed to prevent this. The state where work is performed generally taxes wages earned there, the employee's state of residence generally taxes all of their income, and the resident state typically provides a credit for income tax paid to another state on the same wages. Double taxation tends to arise when states disagree about where the work was performed, most notably when a state taxes nonresident remote employees of in-state employers as if they worked in that state, while the employee's home state considers the work performed at home.
This matters to employers because it shows up in payroll withholding, employee frustration, and retention. One thing employers consistently underestimate is how often a remote employee's tax problem becomes an HR and payroll problem for the business. For the broader obligations a remote hire can create for the business itself, see our article on the multi-state tax trap of hiring remote employees.
How State Taxation of Wages Usually Works
In general, wages are sourced to the state where the employee physically performs the work. An employee who lives and works in the same state is typically taxed only by that state. An employee who lives in one state and commutes or travels to work in another may owe tax to the work state on wages earned there, while the home state taxes all of their income and offers a credit for tax paid to the work state. Some neighboring states have reciprocity agreements that simplify this for commuters, allowing withholding only for the state of residence. The details vary by state.
Where Double Taxation Comes From
Convenience of the Employer Rules
A small number of states, including New York, apply rules under which a nonresident employee working remotely for an employer based in that state may still be taxed by that state on those wages if the remote arrangement is for the employee's convenience rather than the employer's necessity. If the employee's home state treats the same work as performed at home and does not grant a full credit, the employee can end up paying tax to both states on the same income. Whether these rules apply, and how, depends on the specific states involved and the facts, and the rules can change.
Differences in Sourcing and Credit Rules
States do not all calculate credits the same way. Differences in tax rates, how income is allocated, and limits on credits can leave part of an employee's income effectively taxed twice, or leave the employee owing more than expected.
Local Taxes
Some cities and localities impose their own income or wage taxes. Credits between local jurisdictions and states are not always available, which can add another layer of potential overlap.
Incorrect Withholding
Even where no true double taxation exists, payroll that withholds for the wrong state, or for both states without coordination, can create cash flow strain for employees and refund claims to sort out at filing time. In practice, this usually shows up as an employee who moved during the year and whose withholding never followed them.
Why It Becomes an Employer Problem
Employers are generally responsible for withholding state income tax correctly based on the rules of the states involved. Errors can lead to employee complaints, corrected wage statements, and in some cases penalties. Employees facing unexpected tax bills may also view the remote arrangement less favorably, which affects retention and recruiting. And the same remote work arrangements that drive individual tax issues can create payroll registrations and other obligations for the business in new states.
What Employers Can Do
What we see most often is that the employers who handle this well start with accurate data. Track where each employee actually lives and works, including temporary periods in other states. Adopt a policy requiring employees to notify the business before relocating or working from another state for extended periods. Determine the withholding rules for each state combination involved, including any reciprocity agreements and local taxes, and configure payroll to allocate wages correctly when employees work in more than one state (see multi-state payroll processing). Where a state applies convenience-based rules, document whether remote arrangements are required by the business or chosen by the employee, since that distinction can matter. Finally, let employees know that multi-state situations may affect their personal returns and encourage them to seek tax advice, without providing personal tax guidance you are not positioned to give.
Can Employees Avoid Double Taxation Entirely?
A question employers often ask is whether this risk can be eliminated. Often it can be reduced significantly through correct withholding and use of available credits, but in some state combinations it may not be avoided completely under current rules. The specific outcome depends on the states, the nature of the work arrangement, and each employee's circumstances, which is why individual employees should review their situation with a tax professional (see multi-state tax services).
Should This Affect Remote Hiring Decisions?
Another common question is whether employers should avoid hiring in certain states. Usually not by default. But understanding which state combinations create added complexity allows the business to set expectations, plan payroll correctly, and make informed decisions about where remote roles can be based (see remote workforce planning and HR support).
Where to Start
The double taxation risk facing remote workers comes from states disagreeing about where wages are earned, combined with credit limitations and local taxes. Employers cannot change those rules, but accurate work location tracking, correct multi-state withholding, clear remote work policies, and documentation of arrangements reduce problems for employees and the business alike. If you employ remote workers in other states, reviewing how their wages are withheld and sourced is a practical place to start. When you are ready, start a conversation with our team.
